Home —» News —» Dakota MX1-DL vs MX2-DL: the differences between the A-Scan and B-Scan gauges

Dakota MX1-DL vs MX2-DL: the differences between the A-Scan and B-Scan gauges

Dakota NDT MX series instrument for ultrasonic corrosion measurement

A guide comparing the Dakota MX1-DL and MX2-DL corrosion gauges. Both have a 4 GB data logger and a 250 readings/sec scan mode; what sets them apart is the A-Scan display, essential for coded inspections where the ultrasonic signal has to be validated graphically.

The Dakota MX range of ultrasonic corrosion gauges consists of two models: the MX1-DL and the MX2-DL. Both offer an internal 4 GB data logger, high-speed scan mode up to 250 readings per second and the 2D block view for analysing the thickness profile. The key difference lies in the presence of the A-Scan display, which separates an advanced corrosion gauge from an instrument at flaw-detector level.

Dakota MX family of corrosion gauges

The MX1-DL and MX2-DL shared platform

According to the official Dakota NDT specifications, both models in the MX series share:

  • 4 GB internal memory for storing readings and waveforms
  • High-speed Scan mode: up to 250 readings per second
  • Pulse-Echo (PE) and Echo-Echo ThruPaint™ (EE) measurement modes, the latter ignoring coatings up to 2 mm
  • 2D block cross-section view — graphical representation of the thickness profile, useful for identifying pitting and corroded areas
  • Selectable display modes: Readings, B-Scan, B-Scan combined with readings, Scan bar
  • Repeatability/stability indicator with 6 vertical bars
  • Alarm minimum thickness and differential mode
  • USB-C connectivity with integrated file system
  • Integration with the DakMaster™ software for professional reporting

The fundamental difference: the A-Scan display

A-Scan display of the Dakota MX2-DL

The Dakota MX1-DL offers every digital and graphical display mode (Readings, B-Scan, Scan bar) but does not include the A-Scan display. The Dakota MX2-DL, on top of all the MX1-DL functions, adds the A-Scan display with full (RF) or rectified (RECT, positive or negative) waveform. This is the difference that justifies moving up to the higher model.

Why the A-Scan makes the difference

The A-Scan display lets the operator interpret the ultrasonic signal directly instead of relying solely on the numerical value computed by the firmware. Seeing the waveform is essential in the following cases:

  • Validating critical measurements: checking that the back-wall echo is clean and not contaminated by intermediate echoes (inclusions, delaminations, double reflections)
  • Corroded or uneven surfaces: telling a valid echo from a spurious one in difficult geometries
  • Detecting pitting and sub-surface defects: the intermediate peak on the A-Scan flags a defect that a purely numerical reading would miss
  • Inspections to standards: many NDT procedures require the A-Scan to be recorded as evidence of the acquired signal
  • Diagnosing coupling problems: seeing immediately when the couplant gel is insufficient or the probe is not correctly placed

Comparison table

FeatureDakota MX1-DLDakota MX2-DL
Data logger4 GB4 GB
Scan Mode speed250 readings/sec250 readings/sec
Pulse-Echo (PE)YesYes
Echo-Echo ThruPaint™YesYes
2D block viewYesYes
Readings displayYesYes
B-Scan displayYesYes
Scan bar displayYesYes
A-Scan displayNoYes (RF and RECT)
USB-C connectivityYesYes
DakMaster™YesYes

Which one to choose

The choice is driven by how formalised the inspection is:

  • Choose the Dakota MX1-DL if You need a corrosion gauge with data logging and B-Scan, but graphical verification of the signal is not critical to Your procedures
  • Choose the Dakota MX2-DL if You work in regulated contexts (API 570, API 653, customer specifications) where being able to display and store the A-Scan is required as evidence of the quality of the measurement

For help in choosing and to request a demonstration of the Dakota MX instruments, contact our technical office.

Discover more from ULTRASUONI NDT

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading